Woman Refuses To Get Rid Of Her Dog For Her Transgender In-Law, Gets Called Selfish AH

OP’s sibling-in-law, Jay, recently came out as trans and asked to stay with OP and their husband. However, Jay, who doesn’t contribute to dog care, demanded OP get rid of their well-behaved dog, Toto, claiming living with a dog is “society producing.” When OP refused, Jay cried and accused OP of making things worse. OP’s husband, upon hearing about the situation, told Jay to drop the issue or leave. Jay called OP’s mother-in-law crying, seeking validation. OP wonders if they were wrong for not giving up their dog to accommodate Jay.

Scroll down till the end to read the full story.

1. Would someone get rid of their dog due to a guest having problem?

via Reddit

2. OP’s husband’s sibling Jay (34) came out as trans, divorced, and jobless. OP agreed to let them stay with them.

via Reddit

3. Jay, a challenging guest, demanded OP get rid of their well-behaved dog, Toto. Despite not caring for the dog, Jay found living with it unbearable.

via Reddit

4. OP refused. Jay burst into tears, accusing OP of worsening things. OP took Toto and retreated to their room.

via Reddit

5. OP told husband, who told Jay to drop it or leave. Jay called MIL, seeking validation. OP wonders if refusing to give up the dog was wrong.

via Reddit

The story highlights the importance of setting boundaries and standing up for what is important to oneself, even in challenging situations. It illustrates the need for assertiveness and resilience when faced with unreasonable demands, showing that it’s okay to prioritize one’s own values and well-being. Additionally, it emphasizes the significance of open communication within relationships, as seen in the dialogue between OP and their husband. Ultimately, the message conveyed is one of self-respect and the recognition that individuals have the right to maintain their autonomy and make decisions that align with their beliefs, even if it means facing opposition.

Now that you have read the story, it’s time for you to see what Redditors had to say about this. Read till the end to see what are other people’s opinions on this. Don’t forget to share your own opinion at the end of this article.

6. Your dog is family too! NTA for prioritizing their well-being.

7. Your dog is family too! NTA for prioritizing their well-being.

8. Jay needs to respect your boundaries. You’re NTA!

9. Jay’s discomfort doesn’t justify forcing you to give up your dog.

10. OP is the one to decide the rules.

11. NTA for standing up for your furry friend.

12. It is clear that Jay’s request was unreasonable. NTA for refusing.

13. Jay needs to learn some manners.

14. People need to understand pets are family members too.

15. Jay should just leave.

16. People are not happy with Jay being home.

17. Absolutely NTA, your home, your rules.

18. Jay’s discomfort doesn’t justify forcing you to give up your dog.

19. OP’s husband handled it well.

20. One can choose to be kind.

What are your thoughts on this story? What would you do, or how would you react if you were in OP’s position? You know that your feedback means a lot to us; therefore, we want you to share your thoughts in the comment section below. For more such articles, keep visiting Defused. Have a nice day!

Cat tax