Advertisement
in , ,

Dog Owner Asks If They Are Wrong For Not Giving Their Dog Back To Previous Owners After 8 Years

Adopting a pet is a lifelong responsibility that entails providing love, care, and a stable home environment. When individuals decide to bring a furry friend into their lives, they commit to cherish and protect them through thick and thin. However, sometimes unforeseen circumstances arise, leading to difficult decisions about the animal’s welfare. In such situations, it’s essential to consider the pet’s best interests and ensure that decisions prioritize their well-being above all else.

When u/Grace2098 adopted a pup from her friend’s coworker eight years ago, she never expected to be asked to return the dog years later. The dog became a cherished part of her family, but the previous owner now wants her back, claiming her child is old enough for a dog. Refusing to give up their beloved pet, the family stood firm, citing their adoption agreement and the dog’s attachment to them.

Continue scrolling down to delve into the full story.

Source: Reddit

1. Are we wrong for standing our ground and keeping our dog?

Advertisement

2. Around eight years back, OP’s friend’s coworker sought a new home for her dog due to personal and family challenges.

Advertisement

3. The dog perfectly fits the description of the dog OP’s family desired, so they eagerly welcomed her into their home without hesitation.

Advertisement

4. She’s been a constant source of comfort through life’s ups and downs, accompanying them through every milestone and hardship.

Advertisement

5. Fast forward to the present, the previous owner now desires the dog back, feeling ready for a family pet now that her child has grown older.

Advertisement

6. Naturally, OP’s family refused, considering the dog a cherished member of their household, having witnessed her experiences and healed her from past abandonment.

Advertisement

7. Furthermore, they believed it unjust to return the dog to someone who relinquished her due to inconvenience.

8. They are uncertain if their stance is correct, as they may have misunderstood the initial reason for taking her or refusing to return her.

Advertisement

Now that you have read the story, it’s time for you to see what Redditors had to say about this. Read till the end to see what are other people’s opinions on this. 

9. A similar situation happened to a friend who kept the pet. You should do the same; the previous owner abandoned the dog.

10. OP should ensure the pup’s chip details are current!!

Advertisement

11. It’s clear she had no temporary plan; eight years is significant.

12. Either you own the dog now, or she owes you for all expenses incurred during the 8 years if she wants it back.

Advertisement

13. The dog is yours now, so don’t feel guilty about keeping it. You saved the pup, so it belongs to you!!

14. It’s unfair to ask for the dog back after abandoning it for eight years.

Advertisement

15. The previous owner’s stance boils down to treating the pet like an item, stashing it away until convenient, with little regard for its well-being, only to reclaim it at a whim.

16. Taking the dog now seems more about inconvenience than genuine care for the animal.

Advertisement

17. Getting a new dog is a viable option for them.

18. Giving her up would be nothing short of cruelty!!

Advertisement

19. You’ve had the dog for almost a decade. She has no case, ethically or legally.

20. Wanting the dog back after eight years is absurd, especially considering the circumstances. Keep the pup close; it’s the right decision.

Advertisement

The story sparked a lively debate among readers about the responsibilities of pet ownership and the ethical considerations surrounding rehoming. Ultimately, the OP’s decision to keep the dog highlighted the enduring bond between humans and their animal companions, emphasizing the importance of compassion, responsibility, and love in caring for our furry friends. Do share your thoughts on OP’s situation in the comments section below.

Stay tuned for more thought-provoking stories!

Advertisement

What do you think?

Leave a Reply

GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings