Dogs are often considered the most devoted of all pets, with their owners viewing them as integral members of the family. Sometimes, owners even bestow human names upon their dogs and adopt the role of their pets’ guardians. However, it can be unsettling for some individuals to associate a human name with a dog, especially if the name is shared with close acquaintances. When a dog’s name is used in a manner similar to that of a human, it can evoke feelings of degradation.
OP owned a six-year-old female Pyrenees dog named Charlotte. Whenever he needed her to come inside the house after tending to her business, he would call out her name loudly. Recently, OP noticed that new neighbors had moved into the house across his backyard. As usual, when Charlotte went to the yard for her patrol, OP called out her name. However, to his surprise, one of the neighbors paid him a visit after hearing him call out “Charlotte.” Coincidentally, the neighbor’s daughter shared the same name as OP’s dog. When OP clarified that he was calling his dog, not his neighbor’s daughter, the neighbor demanded that he change the dog’s name. Read the full story to discover OP’s response to this request and share your thoughts in the comments below.
Source: Reddit
1. OP is seeking advice on whether it was wrong to refuse his neighbor’s demand to change his dog’s name.

2. OP lived with a six-year-old Great Pyrenees dog named Charlotte. Whenever he wanted her to come back inside the house, he would call her name loudly.

3. While calling for Charlotte to come inside, OP noticed that a new family had moved in next door.

4. As OP called his dog’s name loudly, his neighbor came over and started knocking angrily on his door.

5. OP found out that his neighbor’s daughter was also named Charlotte. He ordered OP to change his dog’s name, expressing concern that his two-year-old daughter might get confused and run to OP’s place.

6. OP declined to change the name of his dog, citing that it was the dog’s original name and he had lived in the neighborhood before the neighbors arrived. Therefore, he saw no reason to comply with the demand.

7. OP’s neighbor was annoyed with OP’s refusal, believing that his daughter’s name held more significance than a dog’s name.

8. OP noticed his neighbor glaring at him when he went into the yard with his dog, Charlotte.

9. OP believes it’s unfair to prioritize humans over dogs.

Now that you’ve read the story, let’s explore what Redditors had to say. Continue reading to uncover various perspectives on the matter.
10. Redditor humorously suggests that OP should get more dogs and name them after his neighbor and his neighbor’s wife.

11. If he is going to do it, then it must be done right!

12. OP is enjoying the ideas shared by people in the comments.

13. Calling the wife’s name is more dangerous then lol!

14. OP should openly install all his cameras to deter his neighbor from committing any crimes.

15. The Redditor suggests that OP install cameras for his protection, but OP is concerned that they won’t be able to prevent the crime, only collect evidence after it has happened.

16. Well, these are some brilliant ideas!

17. Seems like a showdown between a clever dog and an unreasonable neighbor!

18. Of course! It would make the post trend.

19. What a smart dog the Redditor has!

20. According to the Redditor, OP needs to protect his Charlotte from the other Charlotte’s father.

OP’s dog had been accustomed to her name for six years, so it seemed unjust to change it simply to avoid confusion with a new neighbor. Given that it’s possible for two people to share a similar name by chance, why couldn’t a dog have one? If the neighbor was bothered by the similarity, he could consider changing his daughter’s name, especially since she was only two years old, but it wasn’t fair for him to impose that demand on OP. OP should take precautions to protect his dog from any potential harm from the neighbor, who might act out of revenge. What are your thoughts on OP’s situation? Share them in the comments below, and stay tuned to Defused for more stories.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings