Adinaa
OP commissioned a painting of their beloved dog, Burley, after a friendship rift with K. In middle school, K gifted OP a cherished painting of another pet, Moose. This heartfelt gift held great meaning, and OP didn’t ask for it or pay K. They even crafted thoughtful gifts for K without expecting payment. When OP posted about commissioning Burley’s painting, K reacted strongly, wanting to be involved. But the friendship had soured, and OP found it awkward to ask. Things escalated when K asked for payment for the six-year-old Moose painting, prompting OP to seek opinions from mutual friends. Opinions were divided; some agreed with K, while others found her request odd. OP saw both sides but pointed out that K never paid for the gifts they’d made. The situation left OP wondering if they were in the wrong. AITA? In this complex situation, OP’s narration highlights the nuances of friendship, gift-giving, and reciprocity, making it relatable and thought-provoking.
Scroll down to read the full story if you think it is interesting.
OP commissioned a beautiful painting of her late Irish setter, Burley. She and her best friend K drifted apart, unable to bridge the growing distance.
via Reddit
OP’s best friend prioritized a one-year relationship over their 13-year friendship, leading OP to let the friendship fade to avoid further pain.
via Reddit
OP commissioned the painting because K had painted a meaningful portrait of a past pet, Moose, in middle school, making it a sentimental choice.
via Reddit
OP cherishes K’s thoughtful gift of Moose’s portrait, kept for years. OP also crafted gifts for K without expecting payment, emphasizing their friendship’s sentimentality.
via Reddit
OP valued the Moose portrait and believed Burley deserved a similar tribute. However, when OP posted about commissioning Burley’s painting, K became upset for not being asked.
via Reddit
OP understood K’s attachment to Burley, but their strained friendship and recent argument made it awkward to request a painting from her.
via Reddit
K unexpectedly asked OP to pay for the 6-year-old Moose painting. Mutual friends found this request unusual, labeling OP as inconsiderate for not discussing a Burley painting with K.
via Reddit
K had a connection to the previous painting, but OP felt their distant relationship made it uncomfortable to ask for another painting of their own dog, Burley.
via Reddit
K continues to press OP about payment, dividing mutual friends’ opinions. OP sees both perspectives but notes that reciprocity could extend to the gifts they’ve made for K. OP asks AITA?
Now that you have read the story, it’s time for you to see what Redditors had to say about this. Read till the end to see what are other people’s opinions on this. Don’t forget to share your own opinion at the end of this article, too.
It’s unfair for K to ask for payment for a gift she willingly made years ago.
K’s behavior and demands are unreasonable considering your history.
Your decision to commission the painting was personal. You are NTA.
It’s your prerogative to commission a painting for your beloved dog, and K’s expectations are unjustified.
What are your thoughts on this story? What would you do, or how would you react if you were in OP’s position? You know that your feedback means a lot to us; therefore, we want you to share your thoughts in the comment section below. For more such articles, keep visiting Defused. Have a nice day!
Dog tax
“Here is my good boy Bizzy. He’s my best buddy and he’s such a cool and unique boy. My parents adopted him in 2014 and he’s still as handsome as he was then!
I wanted to know if anyone has a similar-looking doggy. He’s so unique and I hardly see dogs that look like him. I’m foggy on his breed and I’m not quite sure what his family looked like, so can anyone help me identify him? Also- does anyone have a puppy that looks like him?”
via doggos
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings