Allergic Brother Tells Sister To Not Adopt A Cat, Even Though He Never Visits, Gets Called Out

OP, a 25-year-old woman, lives alone in a town where she only knows her boyfriend. Working nights as a nurse, she craves companionship and considers adopting a cat. Due to her family’s dog preference and allergies, she never had a cat but feels it’s suitable for her schedule. Despite her brother’s objections, warning of family allergies, OP plans to adopt the cat. She clarifies she won’t bring the cat to family homes and will manage allergies if they visit. Feeling hurt by her brother’s lack of support and considering her efforts to accommodate family needs, OP wonders if she would be wrong to proceed with the adoption.

Scroll down below to read the full story in OP’s own words.

1. OP considers adopting a cat despite family objections due to allergies. She plans to accommodate family visits but feels conflicted.

via Reddit

2. OP, a nurse working night shifts, wants a cat for companionship. Living in a new town, she seeks comfort after exhausting shifts.

via Reddit

3. OP, from a family of dog lovers, can’t get a puppy due to night shifts. Considering adopting a cat from a shelter instead.

via Reddit

4. OP’s brother opposes her cat adoption, citing family allergies. He threatens no family visits for 20 years if she proceeds, calling it disgusting.

via Reddit

5. OP clarifies she won’t take the cat to her hometown. She believes cats can manage alone for a weekend with stocked supplies.

via Reddit

6. OP informs her brother he’s never visited her new town. She’s researched hosting guests with cat allergies and feels prepared to accommodate.

via Reddit

7. OP wonders if she’d be wrong to adopt the cat despite her brother’s objections, considering her efforts to accommodate family allergies.

via Reddit

Now that you have read the story, it’s time for you to see what Redditors had to say about this. Read till the end to see what are other people’s opinions on this. Don’t forget to share your own opinion at the end of this article.

8. Your brother’s opinion shouldn’t dictate your happiness.

9. It’s your life and your decision. Your brother needs to respect that.

10. You’re not obligated to live by your family’s preferences forever.

11. Choosing to adopt a cat doesn’t make you a bad person.

12. It’s important to prioritize your own well-being and desires.

Advertisement

13. That’s a harsh word for him.

14. OP’s brother’s attitude towards her choice is unjustified.

15. Why is adopting a cat a big deal?

16. OP is making a responsible decision by considering the cat’s needs and her lifestyle.

17. People are advising OP to get a cat.

18. Your brother should support you, not guilt-trip you.

19. Your house, your rules, simple.

20. OP’s plan to accommodate family visits shows thoughtfulness but they are just being inconsiderate.

What are your thoughts on this story? What would you do, or how would you react if you were in OP’s position? You know that your feedback means a lot to us; therefore, we want you to share your thoughts in the comment section below. For more such articles, keep visiting Defused. Have a nice day!

Cat tax